# Pathway Reviewer - Final Validation

## Verdict
Approved. All requested success criteria are met.

## Findings
No blocking issues found.

## Criteria Validation
- Hover parity across graph and cards: **Pass**
  - Card hover drives graph highlight via `onNodeHighlight` -> `highlightedNodeId` -> `CareerConstellation` highlight effect.
  - Graph hover drives card highlight via `onNodeHover` -> `highlightedRoleId` consumed by timeline cards.
- Hover jitter/reflow artifacts: **Pass**
  - D3 initialization effect in `CareerConstellation` depends on `dimensions` only.
  - Highlight updates are decoupled via refs/effect (`highlightGraphRef`) and no longer recreate simulation.
- Timeline/card date consistency from one canonical source: **Pass**
  - Canonical entities are defined in `src/data/timeline.ts`.
  - `consultations` and constellation role/edge data are compatibility layers derived from canonical timeline entities.
- Unified career/education card flow and pills: **Pass**
  - `TimelineInterventionsSubsection` renders one ordered list from `timelineEntities`.
  - Career entries show `Career Intervention` pill.
  - Education entries show `Education Intervention` pill and right-aligned layout class.
- Standalone duplicate education section removed: **Pass**
  - `DashboardLayout` uses unified timeline subsection; separate education subsection path is removed.
- Sidebar tags from canonical skill aggregation: **Pass**
  - `src/data/tags.ts` derives tags from `getTopTimelineSkills()` (most frequent first).
- Quality gates: **Pass**
  - `npm run lint`: pass (2 existing warnings, 0 errors)
  - `npm run typecheck`: pass
  - `npm run build`: pass

## Notes
- Validation for "no jitter" is based on lifecycle/code-path inspection plus successful build gates.
- Existing non-blocking warnings remain in context providers (`react-refresh/only-export-components`).